Eight Days That Made Rome – Channel 5

Standard

Ah, this is proper old-fashioned history!   Real “1066 and all that” stuff – big characters and big events.  Eight days which Bettany Hughes deems to have been crucial in the development of the Roman Republic and Empire.  So far, we’ve had Hannibal’s last stand, the Spartacus Revolt and Julius Caesar crossing the Rubicon, and we’ve still got, amongst other things, Boudicca’s uprising and Constantine’s conversion to Christianity to come.  Hannibal, Spartacus, Caesar … names that everyone’s familiar with.  The terms “Spartacist” (although I’m never entirely sure why so many Russian football teams have got “Spartak” in their names, even if Moscow is the Third Rome!), “crossing the Rubicon” and (to some extent) “delenda est Carthago” are still in use.  You can’t really say that about the three field system or the daily lives of medieval monks or some of the other stuff that comes up in school history lessons.  Not that fields and monks aren’t important, but start with the big names and the big events: they’re what get people interested.

And the way in which it’s been presented has been very impressive. Channel 5’s idea of historical drama-documentaries often leaves a lot to be desired, but this has been really good.  The dramatisations have been convincing and not OTT, and Bettany Hughes has done a lot of dramatic striding around across hills and visiting archaeological sites, interviewing present day historians and reading from the works of Roman historians.  It’s all been put together very well … except that the Romans are being made out to be the baddies in everything, and we haven’t even got to Boudicca yet

OK, the Romans did some rather nasty stuff. (Certain elements of Roma and Lazio’s support still do, but that’s beside the point.)  “Nasty” is putting it mildly.  Burying a vestal virgin alive to appease the gods after defeat by Carthage.  Wrecking Carthage and selling the entire population into slavery.  Crucifying thousands of rebel slaves.  They don’t tell you any of this in the Cambridge Latin Course: I bet kids would pay a lot more attention in Latin lessons if they did :-). (Or do teachers think that it would it all be too much for snowflake types?!)  But, come on, we do owe the Romans rather a lot!  Give them some credit for the good things they did, as well as the bad.  Is this just Bettany’s take on things, or is it some sort of PC anti-imperial thing?  Either way, give the Romans a break!

But still, this is turning out to be a very enjoyable series. Roman history gets rather overlooked these days.  May we have a series on the Greeks as well, please?  And preferably one on the Phoenicians and the Carthaginians as well?  Well done, Channel 5 – you don’t always get it right, but this time you definitely have done!

5 thoughts on “Eight Days That Made Rome – Channel 5

  1. Chris Deeley

    I prefer the form “Carthago delenda est” – “Carthage is to be destroyed”. The Carthaginians were, of course, Phoenicians (hence “Punic wars”) – ethnically very similar to the Hebrews. I wonder whether the Jews may have learnt from the Punic calamities (not just Carthage, but also New Carthage in Spain)? I.e. let’s prosper through international trade/banking (coupled with endogamy), but avoid establishing political colonies, which might attract enviable attention and consequent conflict. It’s a theory that I have never encountered, but may have merit.

    Like

    • When I went to Morocco, they told us that the Berber language had always been oral until recently and, when they decided it needed to be written again, they developed an alphabet based on Phoenician, because obviously the Carthaginians were Phoenician. It’s very similar to Hebrew. I’ve never thought of the Hebrews learning from the Phoenicians – Sidon and Tyre and Jezebel and all that! – but it’s an interesting idea.

      Like

      • Chris Deeley

        But the Hebrews would have been well aware of the Phoenicians’ wealth (some of which helped furnish Solomon’s Temple) and may have concluded that there was more to life than goat-herding. An alternative theory is that the Jewish diaspora only commenced after the Roman destruction of the Temple in AD 70. I prefer the first theory! The similarity of the two alphabets is further evidence of a cultural closeness – notwithstanding contrary political/religious assertions in the Old Testament.

        Like

  2. mrsredboots

    The Spartacus one seemed to be mostly extracts from the eponymous film, but I agree, an enjoyable series, if relentlessly negative about the Empire.

    Like

Hello! Please let me know what you think.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.