I’m afraid that I was rather disappointed by this book. I was quite excited by the idea of a book set in a girls’ day school in Manchester. From the location, I think the school’s based on the old Central High School. It had closed down by my day, but I know people of my parents’ generation who went there, and obviously I know Manchester city centre and the other locations mentioned. If anyone reading this *does* decide to try this book, then yes, Boggart Hole Clough is a real place, and that’s its real name! And, yes, Lewis’s was a real shop … it was a lovely shop, and I can’t quite believe that it’s been twelve years since it closed down.
And I knew that there was a supernatural element, but I thought that that might work quite well. A lot of teenagers are interested in the supernatural. I know that some girls at my school did try using ouija boards, although that was possibly due more to the Morrissey song than anything else! However, unfortunately, the style of writing in this book was rather poor, and the storyline was rather weak and didn’t really hang together.
The book’s had some good reviews, so maybe I’m missing something; but I just wasn’t very impressed by it.
It started off as a poor man’s Judy Blume book, with a lot of talk about X being friends with Y, X and Y not liking Z, parents and teachers thinking that X was a bad influence on Y, and so on. The protagonist, Sally, was friendly with a girl called Pamela, who was seen as being a bit rough. They didn’t get on with a girl called Sylvia, and Pamela played a nasty prank which caused Sylvia a lot of distress. However, there was also some talk about ghosts in the toilets (why would ghosts be in school toilets, of all places?), and Sally started to think that Sylvia had a doppelganger, because she was sure that she’d seen her in two places at once. Then, apparently under the influence of the fake Sylvia, Pamela took her own life by jumping off the school roof. Sylvia had a nervous breakdown and left school. It was clear that something was very wrong with both girls’ home lives, but we never really found out exactly what.
We then fast forwarded through Sally’s university years, to a time when the school had closed down and the building had been converted with flats, and Sally had reunited with Rob, her old boyfriend from her schooldays. And, whaddaya know, he was living in one of the flats in the old school building. Sally moved in with him, but kept thinking that she could feel a supernatural presence there. Rob tried to help by tracking down Sylvia, and it ended up with Sally tripping down some stairs to her death, and Rob and Sylvia getting together.
Sorry, but I didn’t get it. I think we were meant to feel that the portrayal of Sally’s terror and her uncertainty about what was real and what was her imagination were very powerful, but it just didn’t work for me. Oh well, we can’t all like the same things!